Can you lose your inheritance by going to court? Forfeiture clauses in wills after the Supreme Court's recent ruling (3758-05-26)
The essentials in brief
Many wills contain a so-called forfeiture clause, that is, a provision by which the testator stipulates that an heir who contests the will forfeits everything bequeathed to him, or receives only a token sum. But what happens when a spouse, without contesting the will, applies to the court to claim his or her share of the assets accumulated during the couple's life together? The Supreme Court has now settled the rule: everything depends on what the testator knew and intended. If the testator was aware of those rights and clearly imposed a choice between the inheritance and legal action, the clause applies. If the testator was unaware of those rights, or if his intention remains doubtful, a reasonable claim brought in good faith does not cause the inheritance to be lost. In plain terms: a forfeiture clause only produces its effects if it is drafted with precision. Unless the testator clearly imposed that choice, it does not apply to a spouse who, in good faith and without contesting the will, applies to the court to claim his or her share of the joint assets, as conferred by the matrimonial property regime, in addition to the share bequeathed by the will. If you are drafting a will, or hesitating to bring a claim against an estate, have the clause reviewed before taking any step.
Read on: the detailed article below sets out the judgment and its references.
A woman lived with her partner as his common-law spouse (yedua batsibur, ידועה בציבור) from around 1995, married him in 2015 and was widowed in 2018. In a will drawn up as early as 1998, the deceased left her works of art and percentages of shares in several companies; the shares in the main company went to his two children from a previous marriage. Clause 7 of the will provided that anyone who objected to the probate of the will or to any of its provisions, "for any reason whatsoever", would receive nothing from the estate except a symbolic one shekel.
In 2020 the widow filed a claim for community property, seeking half of the active appreciation of the company accumulated during the years of their life together. She did not attack the will. A few days later, a probate order was granted at her request, without any objection. Some months afterwards, the children answered with a claim of their own: to enforce the forfeiture clause against her, on the ground that her property claim breached both the will and a written undertaking that she and they had signed towards the deceased in 2015, in which each of them promised to respect his wishes.
The question that reached the Supreme Court fits in one sentence: does a property claim that does not challenge the validity of the will, but rests on the property relations between spouses, trigger a clause worded as a prohibition on "objecting to the will"?
What the lower courts decided
The Family Court in Tel Aviv-Jaffa (file 62952-05-20, judgment given in 2025) recognised the widow's right to about 32% of the company's shares, or their value, roughly NIS 20 million (rounded figure), but enforced the forfeiture clause against her and stripped her of what the will had given her. The Tel Aviv District Court (appeal 23006-06-25, judgment given in 2026) reduced her share to roughly NIS 6 million (rounded figure) and, by a majority, upheld the forfeiture. One judge dissented.
The distinction drawn by the Supreme Court
In a judgment given in 2026 (leave to appeal 3758-05-26), written by Justice Alex Stein with the concurrence of Justices David Mintz and Yael Wilner, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal.
The starting point is section 44(a) of the Succession Law, 5725-1965: a testator may direct that an heir shall cease to take upon the fulfilment of a condition. A forfeiture clause (tniyat silukin, תניית סילוקין), known in common-law systems as an in terrorem or no-contest clause, is one instance of such a condition subsequent. Its limit is section 34 of the same Law, which voids any testamentary provision whose performance would be illegal, immoral or impossible; through that door the right of access to the courts enters the law of wills.
The Court distinguishes two types of clause. A no-contest clause targets a beneficiary who attacks the validity of the will itself, on grounds internal to succession law: the testator's incapacity, duress, threat, undue influence, trickery or fraud. A no-claim clause targets a beneficiary who seeks to reduce the estate by relying on a cause of action external to succession law, first among them the Spouses (Property Relations) Law, 5733-1973. A single clause may fall into both categories; that is how clause 7 was classified here.
For no-contest clauses the test has been settled since the Engelman case (CA 245/85): an heir who raises in good faith an objection that is reasonable in the circumstances does not lose his share. For no-claim clauses the position was less clear. The Court now holds that the passage in the Yona case (CA 2698/92) which extended that test to claims against the estate was obiter dictum, and it lays down a framework of three situations.
An express offer. The testator knew of the beneficiary's rights and expressly offered a choice: the share in the estate, or the claim. The clause is enforced in full, even if the claim is reasonable and brought in good faith.
A mistake. The testator wrongly believed that all the assets were his and did not know of his spouse's community property rights. The rules on mistake in wills then apply, and the court asks what the testator would have directed had he known the true position.
A doubtful offer. It cannot be determined whether the testator knew and meant to offer a choice, or was mistaken. Here the right of access to the courts prevails: the clause is enforced only subject to the good faith and reasonableness test, and the beneficiary keeps his share if the claim was reasonable and brought in good faith.
The Court did not hold that the widow may keep both her community property rights and her bequest. It returned the case to the Family Court in Tel Aviv-Jaffa to classify clause 7 under this framework and rule accordingly. It also noted that broad wording such as "for any reason whatsoever" does not settle whether the testator understood what he was asking his beneficiaries to give up, since property rights between spouses are usually neither registered nor known before death.
What this means in practice
For a beneficiary under a will: before filing a property claim against an estate, read the will to the end. A clause worded as a ban on "objecting to the will" may be classified as a no-claim clause. The questions to check: what exactly the clause prohibits, whether the testator knew of the community property rights when the will was drawn up, and whether there is a separate document, such as a written undertaking, signed by the beneficiary.
For a surviving spouse: community property rights that were not documented during the marriage become, after death, a question of proof. A prenuptial or property agreement, or at least a written record of the contribution to the joint business, avoids this litigation.
For anyone drawing up a will: if the intention is to bar only a challenge to the validity of the will, say so. If the intention is to offer the spouse a choice between the inheritance and a claim to her rights, state expressly that the testator is aware of those rights and offers that choice. A vague clause produces exactly the dispute the testator wanted to avoid.
This article is general information and does not constitute legal advice.


Comments