Can a developer enlarge the project without the landowners' consent? Combination transactions after the Supreme Court ruling of 18/10/2026
The essentials in brief
In a so-called combination transaction, a landowner transfers the land to a developer, who builds on it and delivers a number of apartments in return. The Supreme Court has now confirmed that a developer who builds beyond what the contract allows risks outright cancellation of the transaction. In this case, the contract set a cap of 24 apartments, and any excess was defined as a fundamental breach. The developers obtained a plan allowing 38 apartments, without informing the owners, who discovered it only later. The courts held that the owners were entitled to rescind the contract, that the cautionary notes registered in the land registry had to be deleted, and that the powers of attorney given to the developers were revoked. The Court added that a developer acting under a power of attorney is bound, like any agent, to act in the owner's interest and to keep him informed. In plain terms: where a detailed contract sets a numerical limit, the courts apply it to the letter. If you are considering a combination transaction, make sure the contract specifies the maximum number of apartments, the nature of the consideration, the scope of the power of attorney and the developer's duty to inform, and keep every document.
Read on: the detailed article below sets out the judgment and its references.
The owners of four flats in a building at 42 Nitai Haarbeli Street, Jerusalem (block 30144, parcel 192), signed combination agreements with two developers on 15/04/2010. A combination transaction (iskat kombinatsia, עסקת קומבינציה) is simple in principle: the owners transfer part of their rights in the land to the developer and receive in return flats in the building to be built. Here the owners' consideration was fixed in advance and did not depend on how much building would eventually be approved.
Clause 6.2 of the agreements provided that the developer "shall not apply for approval of a plan permitting residential construction exceeding 24 housing units in the building". Clause 25.5 defined a breach of that undertaking as a fundamental breach (hafara yesodit, הפרה יסודית), the kind of breach that entitles the injured party to rescind the contract. Clause 6.9, for its part, obliged the developers to maximise the building rights. The whole case turned on those two clauses.
What happened
The first town planning scheme was approved only in August 2015, well after the contractual deadlines. In 2017, after the owners complained about the delay, a supplementary agreement was signed: a one-off payment (NIS 30,000 to some of the owners and NIS 70,000 to others) and NIS 5,000 a month from February 2018. By then the developers were already working on an enlarged scheme, and said nothing about it.
On 03/11/2019 a new scheme was published permitting up to 38 housing units; 31 were actually planned. The owners first heard of it at a meeting on 10/11/2020. On 22/02/2021 their lawyer gave notice of rescission. The developers rejected it, and the owners contracted with another developer. In February 2022 the original developers sued for specific performance of the agreements; the owners counterclaimed for a declaration that the agreements had been rescinded.
The District Court judgment
The Jerusalem District Court (file 17285-02-22, judgment of 29/09/2025) dismissed the claim for enforcement and allowed the counterclaim. The breach of clause 6.2 was a fundamental breach, compounded by a breach of the duties of disclosure and good faith. Since the owners' consideration was fixed, every unit beyond the twenty-fourth was profit for the developers alone, at the owners' expense. The duty to maximise under clause 6.9 operates only within the 24-unit cap. Planning notices that the authorities allegedly sent to the owners are no substitute for direct disclosure by the developer. The defences of waiver, delay and limitation were rejected, and the notice of rescission was held to have been given within a reasonable time of the actual discovery of the breach.
The Supreme Court
On 18/10/2026 the Supreme Court dismissed the developers' appeal (CA 22103-12-25), in a judgment by Justice Alex Stein with the concurrence of Justices Gila Canfy-Steinitz and Ruth Ronen. The appeal was dismissed without a hearing under regulation 138(a)(5) of the Civil Procedure Regulations, 5779-2018, the Court finding no ground to interfere with the trial court's findings of fact.
The Court added a layer of its own: a developer who holds a power of attorney from the landowners is their agent, and owes the heightened duties of section 8 of the Agency Law, 5725-1965, among them loyalty and disclosure. A power of attorney given to advance the project is no authority to transform it. Relying on the Bibi Kvishim case (CA 7649/18), the Court restated that a detailed commercial contract is enforced according to its terms.
The remedies were confirmed in full: rescission of the agreements, cancellation of the cautionary notes (hearot azhara, הערות אזהרה) registered at the Land Registry in favour of the developers, and revocation of the powers of attorney.
What to take from this before signing a combination agreement
The owners won this case in 2010, not in court. The contract set a numerical ceiling and defined exceeding it as a fundamental breach. Without those two provisions the outcome might have been different: an increase in the number of units is not automatically a fundamental breach, and the answer depends on the wording of the contract, the scale of the change and its economic consequences.
Points to check in the contract: the maximum number of housing units, and what happens if the developer wants to exceed it; whether the owners' consideration is fixed or proportional to the volume built; what exactly the power of attorney authorises; and the developer's duty to report any change to the project.
A supplementary agreement signed while the developer already knows of a planned change and keeps quiet about it, like the 2017 agreement in this case, does not cure the breach. Keep every document: agreements, plans, permit applications, powers of attorney, correspondence with the developer and notices from the authorities. It was the date of actual discovery that determined here whether the notice of rescission was given in reasonable time.
This article is general information and does not constitute legal advice.


Comments